WAVV Requirement Form[Informati1] 

 

Date: 08/29/2006                                         Requirement #:  WAVV200706

Product Name:   z/VM   Product Release# (or state “current”): Current

Vendor Name:    IBM

 

Title: Provide emulated ECKD devices delivered over SCSI  drives

Detailed Problem Description: Complete the emulated device over SCSI/FCP support introduced in z/VM 4.4 and 5.x to include emulation of ECKD DASD on generic SCSI/FCP disk devices.

                                                                                             

Priority: High      Requested Completion Date: Next Release         Requirement Type: Compatibility/Migration

 

Business Justification: In many small to medium-sized shops, the amount of money available to invest in mainframe technology is limited compared to the funding accessible to the open systems environment. Often, significant disk resources are duplicated or over-provisioned in the open systems environment, but are not accessible for reuse in the mainframe environment due to the requirement for specialized interfaces and separate management to support mainframe-specific environments. Enabling software emulation of mainframe devices on top of a generic SCSI/FCP infrastructure would allow System z infrastructure to leverage these existing enterprise infrastructure investments directly, improving the TCO argument for maintaining System z-based infrastructure.   (It is clearly acknowledged that software emulation has a performance impact compared to native performance)

Even given the recent price reductions for the System z BC and EC machines, in some cases, the cost differential to implement separate disk for a System z environment (or add specialized interfaces to support FICON attachment of an existing disk array) is such that pricing is a deciding factor to preserve a System z environment.  Similarly, environmental issues (floor space, power consumption, heat dissipation) may dictate that additional disk units to support only a single platform argue against retaining the System z solution as a "difficult to interoperate with" solution.

Currently, only VSE, Linux and VM fully support FBA DASD. We are aware of work being done to z/OS to tolerate FBA disk, but until this work is completed, ECKD disk is required.  If IBM is to open up additional market opportunity for z/OS or other ECKD-only systems in the short term, ECKD emulation is necessary to open those opportunities. 

It is important to note that ECKD emulation on SCSI disk has been done in the past for the P/390, R/390, and Multiprise systems, and it is clear from a cursory examination of the z/VM EDEV SCSI stack that these previous attempts could be used as a starting point to provide this type of emulated function.

As z/OS continues to postpone implementation of FBA DASD, the ability to support z/OS and other older systems that rely on ECKD DASD relies on the availability of ECKD disk. This cannot be accomplished without emulation in a SCSI-only system.  

There is also a security advantage in that encryption devices for SCSI devices are substantially less expensive than replacing existing channel-attached devices, and can participate in a enterprise-wide key management process that does not need native OS support.

Impact: Further argument to remove the mainframe and replace with "more compatible" device.

 

Author Name:      David Boyes                                          Author Title: President/CTO

Company Name:Sine Nomine Associates                                                                                      

Address: 43596 Blacksmith Square, Ashburn, VA 2017 USA

Author E-mail:     dboyes@sinenomine.net                 Telephone: (703)723-6673             


 [Informati1]Please be precise and short.   The Benefit section is extremely important – please make a business case.Proofread - recheck accuracy of contact information before saving.File as unique name-WRvviinn, where vv=vendor initials, ii=your initial, ‘nn’ to number each requirement.  Ex.: Wribwm01 ib=IBM, wm=wayne merySubmit your labeled diskette (with your full name) to the requirements coordinator, a black shirt WAVV manager, the registration desk or copy it to the root drive of a registration or workroom PC.*